diff --git a/content/blog/small-acts-of-murder-shame-religion-and-what-we-owe-each-other.md b/content/blog/small-acts-of-murder-shame-religion-and-what-we-owe-each-other.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..d1ddcee --- /dev/null +++ b/content/blog/small-acts-of-murder-shame-religion-and-what-we-owe-each-other.md @@ -0,0 +1,126 @@ +--- +title: "Small Acts of Murder: Shame, Religion, and What We Owe Each Other" +description: "Thoughts on regret, murder as a spectrum of harm to quality of life, and arriving at a moral philosophy." +date: 2026-10-10 +tags: + - Atheism + - Life + - Moral Philosophy + - Religion +synopsis: "Thoughts on regret, murder as a spectrum of harm to quality of life, and arriving at a moral philosophy." +imageURL: /img/remorse-albert-sterner.webp +imageAlt: "Remorse, by Albert Sterner. An illustration of a figure collapsed on a bed with their face in the pillow." +--- +Years ago, I broke up with someone abruptly. She and my friend were over. The +two began arguing. Upset, she ran outside into the rain. My friend commented +that she was being ridiculous, that I should break up with her. I'm not usually +so impressionable as to take such an action based on an offhand comment, but I +had been feeling a little uncomfortable in this new relationship. While she was +pleasant, kind, and beautiful, the relationship had mostly been physical and I +was troubled that she hadn't told me much about herself—although I had been +asking. I was young and new to relationships, with all of the anxiety that +accompanies inexperience. I found her standing at the end of the street, +crying. If this happened today, I'd say something reassuring. I'd comfort her, +bring her inside, and explain how I had been feeling at a better time. Instead, +I looked into her tearful eyes and ended it then and there. I was young, +inexperienced, and scared. I really just wanted to get to know her better. +Instead I hurt her in a cruel way. By entering into a relationship, she +entrusted me with the power to hurt her. I abused that trust. To this day I +burn with shame when thinking back on the memory. + +I tend to think of murder as a spectrum upon which loss of life is the extreme +end. Economic slavery imposed by capitalism demands large amounts of time from +finite lives to enrich a wealthy few. Systemic bigotry erodes quality of life +every day. Individual actions turn small moments into unhappy memories. Life +can be impacted in innumerable ways both systemic and interpersonal—beyond +simply cutting it short, the extreme end of a spectrum of harm. Especially to a +materialist, this view lends a new gravity to harms of all sizes. Each action +or inaction that causes pain to another represents a permanent mar on another's +experience, a sliver of one precious existence worsened or ruined. No matter +how trifling, each represents an injury to life itself. + +I don't believe in objective morality, either. In the view of this atheist and +anti-theist, the universe is indifferent to suffering. There's no "good book" +with all the answers. This being the case, morality becomes a logical exercise: +if we hold every sentient life as precious and irreplaceble, how do we model +our behaviors and our society so as to maximize the quality of each? +Unfortunately, grappling with this question is the work of a lifetime. + +I was raised to believe that morality came from a book. God doesn't want us +drinking coffee, hence drinking coffee is immoral. Most religions cover the +basics—plus a few wacky and harmful inclusions—but the topic of morality is too +complex for any tome to do justice. Further, religion fails to offer a sound +logical framework for thinking about morality. As a result, followers think +they're doing fine if they're following at least most of the instructions, and +in some popular traditions there's repentance to boot. This doesn't tend to +work out very well +[even in the short-term](https://www.azquotes.com/quote/702126), but when the +scales fall from the eyes of the faithful and they break free of magical +thinking, they are left morally adrift: with no way of considering how they +ought to interact with others beside their personal feelings. + +Developing a personal moral philosophy is not a simple matter. None of the +great philosophers seem to have arrived at a complete answer, so what hope has +the average person when they discover their entire worldview was bunk? Many +important conversations were skipped in favor of indoctrination, so those freed +from the mental shackles of religion find themselves behind their secular peers +in terms of moral development and understanding. Couple that with years spent +living in a reactionary environment, and it makes for a lot of catching up to +do while also trying to survive in a capitalist society barely less indifferent +to sentient life than the vacuum of space. + +Despite all of this, I sometimes find the recollection of the suffering I've +caused difficult to bear. It is some comfort to know that, like most, I never +meant to cause harm. Most of us do our worst when we think we're in the right, +don't know better, or simply aren't thinking at all. But the tragedy of harm is +its irrevocability. Just as the ways I have been hurt live on in me, I can +never erase the painful memories I've caused. + +If we owe each other one thing and nothing else, it is to respect each-other's +time, both in quantity and quality. We're not born knowing how. It takes a +lifetime of listening, learning, experience, and practice—hurting others all +the while. Even with every effort, fallablility is simply part of the human +condition. One of the few sound pieces of advice I received as a Mormon child +was to consider scenarios that ask you to make a moral decision, and decide now +what you will do when they occur. It may not be so easy to choose in the +moment, so make the decision before it becomes difficult. This system isn't +perfect, but you can certainly consider the kind of person you want to be and +how you want to affect others. Hopefully you get it right. Hopefully, with +time, your ideals become instinct. Hopefully, you maintain the cognitive flexibility such that they are never rendered immutable. + +Perhaps, as +[terror management theory](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terror_management_theory) +would have it, this way of entwining morality with mortality itself is a means +of assuaging death anxiety. Maybe the idea is that, if we must walk into +oblivion, we should do it hand in hand with smiles on our faces, rather than +pecking at each others eyes like hens in a battery cage. Surely, as nature +demands that we spend our lives scraping for its necessities while it awaits +our demise like a circling vulture, our principal aim ought to be to free +ourselves from this cruel status quo? To make possible the full development of +our personalities? To experience, together, the fullness of what it is to be +conscious in freedom from want and suffering? Why shouldn't life itself be at +the root of our thinking around morality? After all, we owe each other +everything. From the earth that made our existence a possibility, the bees that +pollinate our food, the person who laundered the linens we were born on, who +introduced our parents, who stitched our shoes, who taught us to read, who +shared our first kiss… our obligation to everything and everyone around us is +infinite. The idea that any sentient being is beneath moral consideration must +be put to rest. We owe each other—and we each are owed—everything! + +In light of this overwhelming debt, the preciousness of sentient life, +sometimes I don't know what to do with the weight of my shame. Although I have +no children, I often recall a quote by Mitch Albom on parenthood: + +> All parents damage their children. It cannot be helped. Youth, like pristine +> glass, absorbs the prints of its handlers. Some parents smudge, others crack, a +> few shatter childhoods completely into jagged little pieces, beyond repair. + +This idea can surely be extended to encompass all human relationships, given +adequate time. Maybe it is the best we can do to take our guilt, with both +sorrow and gratitude, as a pattern for our own pair of white gloves to help us +handle the lives about us with due care. Since my life has become more stable I +have had the time and headspace to consider the past. I find myself hoping that +the most I have left with others are fingerprints, that the pain I have caused +is mostly a small part of a larger happy memory. When I consider the type of +person I'd like to be, it is one who shares in the sorrow he causes. I can take +solace in the fact that I am at least this. diff --git a/public/img/remorse-albert-sterner.webp b/public/img/remorse-albert-sterner.webp new file mode 100644 index 0000000..683baa2 Binary files /dev/null and b/public/img/remorse-albert-sterner.webp differ